The Cyclobutanone Challenge invited the nonadiabatic dynamics community to predict the photochemistry of cyclobutanone photoexcited at 200 nm, as well as the resulting time-resolved MeV ultrafast electron diffraction (UED) signal, before the experiment was performed at the SLAC MeV-UED facility. Contributors had approximately six months to carry out simulations and submit their predictions as manuscripts to the Journal of Chemical Physics. The challenge attracted 15 theoretical predictions from 74 researchers, employing a wide range of electronic structure and nonadiabatic molecular dynamics approaches. After submission, experimental data from SLAC and Shanghai Jiao Tong University provided reference signals for comparison.
In this roundtable, we will review the motivation, design, participation, and outcomes of the challenge, and then open the discussion to broader topics, including lessons learned and perspectives on future community-driven initiatives.
The discussion will feature three participants: Two of them served as Guest Editors for the special collection in the Journal of Chemical Physics: Basile Curchod, who will overview the theoretical background and implementation of the challenge; Sara Bonella, who will place the effort in the broader context of community activities supported by CECAM. In addition, Alice Green, who co-led the planning and execution of the UED experiment, will discuss the experimental perspective.