Skip to main content

VWSCC logo Virtual Winter School on Computational Chemistry

CET

Cecam Logo

Erosion of Scientific Integrity Fueled by Quantitative Evaluation Metrics – A Case Study in Theoretical Chemistry

Wednesday 28th Jan 2026

Madrid Institute for Advanced Studies, IMDEA Nanoscience
Spain
09:00 CET

Please log in to be able to watch

Erosion of Scientific Integrity Fueled by Quantitative Evaluation Metrics – A Case Study in Theoretical Chemistry

Johannes Gierschner

Madrid Institute for Advanced Studies, IMDEA Nanoscience, Madrid, Spain


Abstract:

In the last few years, the scientific community has been increasingly concerned by malpractice behaviour, which does not fit the classic description of 'scientific misconduct' (summarized as 'falsification, fabrication, plagiarism' - FFP[1]). Nevertheless, these practices, “below the tip of the iceberg”, appear to be not less threatening to the community as they come as a steady erosion, now evolving into a landside. This concerns in particular 'CV polishing' by hyperprolific authorship, and 'citation gaming' through 'citation cartels' and 'paper mills',[2] not only threatening the 'scientific currency' of reputation, but likewise assaulting the business model of data suppliers. In fact, a total of staggering 35% of the researchers were removed since 2021 from Clarivate's 'highly cited researcher' (HCR) list due to system gaming.[3]

Starting from a case study in Theoretical Chemistry, the seminar dissects quantitative and qualitative aspects of the current dissemination crisis, and shows how the ‘publish or perish’ culture, driven by the incentives of funding bodies, institutions, data suppliers and (mostly private) publishers, erodes scientific thinking and working, generating a tsunami of low-quality content publications. Evidently, the steep increase of malpractice in the last years is driven by metrics-based quantitative evaluation, which favours quantity over quality;[4] consequently, we elucidate how number of papers, journal impact factor, and number of citations are systematically gamed to such an extent that the whole system of scientific dissemination is about to implode.

We advocate for an end of scientific hyper-proliferation by returning to 'quality over quantity' in evaluation and publishing,[5] based on the principles of modesty, integrity & autonomy, and to regain control on the definition of quality and impact, and the modus operandi of scientific communication. Only in doing so, science is able to retrieve its incorruptible voice in times of grand challenges ahead.

Keywords:

metrics-based quantitative evaluation, citation gaming, CV polishing, paper mill, scientific hyperproliferation, junk science

Suggested Reading:

[1] see e.g. (a) DFG Guidelines for Safeguarding Good Research Practice; (b) European Code of Conduct for Research Integrity; (c) J. Mehlich, Good Chemistry: Methodological, Ethical, and Social Dimensions, RSC Publishing 2021.

[2] for further reading on relevant aspects, see link collection at www.uv.es/jogiers/ethics.html.

[3] (a) Clarivate's 2025 HCR analysis; (b) see e.g. the analysis in El País.

[4] J. Z. Muller, The Tyranny of Metrics, Princeton University Press 2018.

[5] see e.g. (a) Declaration on Research Assessment (DORA); (b) Coalition for Advancing Research Assessment (COARA)

No comments